Flat Feet And Overpronation

On Friday night, a patient sent me a message with pictures (above) regarding her daughter's flat feet. She was worried that it was affecting her knee, hip and lower back. Subsequently, she brought her daughter into the clinic to see me yesterday. 

Her daughter has increased her running and training more recently for her National School Games bowling competition in the first week of May. She just started having mild pain in her left foot on Friday. Because of the pain, my patient was worried about her daughter's "over" pronation. 

The readers following this blog will recall that I have written before that children from 11 months to 19 years old with flat feet are perfectly fine and do not need orthotics. You can view the Cochrane review here. 

"Over" pronation is a word that is often used by many healthcare professionals to tell their patients that it is a cause of their foot pain. However EVERYONE has to pronate when they walk or run. When you take a step forward while walking, you often land on your heels. After heel strike, the whole foot lands on the ground and this is when your foot pronates. Now imagine having insoles or orthotics to block that movement. That is what happens when you try to limit pronation.

This mechanism is very necessary otherwise no load will be distributed up the leg. In fact, it often does not cause issues in runners. And yet, patients are somehow steered and asked to avoid, limit or alter pronation at all cost.

Of course there may be occasions when you have pain in your foot or arch, and healthcare professionals may have to take the load off the area temporarily to alleviate the structures that have been irritated.

The following study by Nielsen et al (2013) published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine investigated whether newbie runners with different foot positions had more or less injuries by wearing a neutral shoe regardless of their foot type or mechanics.

The 927 newbie runners with different pronation types were followed for a period of 12 months. All the runners received the same pair of neutral running shoes regardless of whether they had neutral foot pronation or not.  

The runners accumulated a total of 163, 401 km that year. 252 runners suffered a running injury in that period. In addition, the number of injuries per 1,000 km of running was significantly lower among runners who under or over pronate than among those with neutral foot pronation.

The authors found "no risk that overpronation or underpronation can lead to running injuries through using neutral shoes for this special group of healthy beginners." The authors "compared runners with neutral foot pronation with the runners who pronate to varying degrees, and our findings suggest that overpronating runners do not have a higher risk of injury than anyone else."

The authors thought their findings were 'controversial', since it has been assumed for many years that one would risk injuries to run in shoes without the necessary support if you under or over pronate.

The study also found that the risk of injury was the same for all their runners after the first 250 km, irrespective of their pronation type. 

Note that the study did not look at what can happen if runners run in a pair of non neutral shoes nor did they investigate what runners should consider with respect to pronation and choice of shoe if they are already injured.

So as I explained to my patient and her daughter whose foot pain has gone away, that pronation or more accurately, overpronation is not to be feared.

References

Nielsen RO, Buist I, Parner T et al (2013). Foot Pronation Is Not Associated With Increased Injury Risk In Novice Runners Wearing A Neutral Shoe: A 1-Year Prospective Cohort Study. BJSM. DOI: 1136/bjsports-2013-092202.